Susan Marie Martin - Interdisciplinary Writer & Researcher
  • Home
  • Books
    • Dublin's Women Street Traders 1882-1932
    • The Shawlies
  • Publications
    • Articles & Book Reviews
    • Research Projects
  • Presentations
  • Snippets
    • Foucault Notebook
    • Another long-winded lady (flâneuse)
    • From the margins (gentrification & the urban poor)

"his work as a toolbox"

14/8/2020

0 Comments

 
Foucault's work is viewed by some as unfathomable.  

I remember my first encounter with his work via the concept of governmentality - reading, re-reading aloud, making notes, re-reading, and then it made sense.  This was early in my MA studies and the course, taught by a Foucaultian, used his work almost exclusively to make sense of how the law is used in global governance.  From that moment of recognition, I moved on to Discipline and Punish which instantly helped me, a secondary teacher at the time, to make sense of the neoliberal downloads of practices into Ontario's secondary schools.  From that point it became difficult to make sense of the problems and populations that became the object of my studies without turning to Michel Foucault for help.  

Five years later, he would serve as the central theorist in my doctoral dissertation on women street traders - the 'heavy' behind both my theoretical framework and my methodology.

Thus, I am delighted to recall that he thought of his work as a 'toolbox' for others to use.  An inspiration, guide, and mentor - his work is both accessible and an 'assistive technology' of sorts.

"Foucault nicely expresses the idea of his work as a toolbox in the following comments in a 1974 interview about his expectations for Discipline and Punish:  'I want my books to be a sort of toolbox that people can rummage through to find a tool they can use however they want in their own domain...I want the little book that I plan to write on disciplinary systems to be of use for teachers, wardens, magistrates, conscientious objectors.  I don't write for an audience, I write for users, not readers.' " (emphasis added)

​More late-night reading of Foucault:  A Very Short Introduction ​by Gary Gutting (112-113).  The extract is taken from '
Prisons et asiles dans le mécanisme du pouvoir’ in Daniel Defert and Francois Ewald (eds.), Dits et écrits, 1954-1988, four volumes (Paris:  Gallimard, 1994), pages 523-4.
0 Comments

"...a historical causal explanation..."

5/8/2020

0 Comments

 
From Foucault:  A Very Short Introduction by Gary Gutting.  Oxford University Press.

Page 47:  "The forces that drive our history do not so much operate on our thoughts, our social institutions, or even our environment as on our individual bodies.  So, for example, punishment in the 18thC is a matter of violent assaults on the body:  branding, dismemberment, execution, whereas in the 19thC it takes the apparently gentler but equally physical form of incarceration, ordered assemblies, and forced labour.  Prisoners are subjected to a highly structured regimen designed to produce 'docile bodies'.  A Foucaultian genealogy, then is a historical causal explanation that is material, multiple, and corporeal."

This aligns with the observation that there does not have to be a straight line from a single event/action/thought/process in the past to a given outcome in the present.  Thoughts and institutions, etc., are not omitted among the "forces that drive our history" but the actions on the body are more powerful in cementing those forces and the continued shaping of thoughts, social institutions, and the environment.

This operates outside of the example of crime and punishment.  Application:  schools and codes of conduct. 
  • The students are given a dress code that includes not only dress but a checklist for physical appearance (i.e., visible tattoos and piercings) that operates on the individual body
  • Observations and classifications are made about 'socially appropriate dress' and corresponding judgements (operates on thoughts)
  • Becomes part of the culture of the institution and, ultimately, the 'environment' of that institution​
  • Continued action on the body (dress, personal appearance) creates a visual that encourages compliance, makes the 'offender' stand out, and serves as a visual reminder of what is not acceptable; disciplinary action (stopping the student in the halls, questioning) serves as a caution to others to encourage continued compliance.
​What is the problem that requires a genealogy?  Particular students are disproportionately affected by the school's code of conduct and government policy.
0 Comments
    Picture

    Archives

    August 2020

    Categories

    All
    Code Of Conduct
    Compliance
    Discipline And Punish
    Food Supply Chains
    Foucault
    Genealogy
    Historical Sociology
    Methods
    Social Sciences
    Theoretical Framework

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.